Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, United States
+1 516-935-8800
$$$ Restaurant
(408 Reviews)
Price Range $20–30

Discover a delightful dining experience at Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria, a cherished gem located at 635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY. This vibrant establishment captures the essence of traditional Italian cuisine, coupled with an inviting atmosphere that feels just like home.

Mario's is known for its expertly crafted pizzas, making it a must-visit for pizza aficionados. Sink your teeth into their BBQ Chicken Pizza, where tender, sweet BBQ chicken is perfectly balanced with gooey mozzarella – a menu favorite that has consistently garnered rave reviews. For a lighter option, don't miss the Marinara Slice, which tantalizes with a blend of fresh vegetables like broccoli, mushrooms, and spinach, all smothered in their rich marinara sauce.

If you're craving something hearty, explore their pasta selections. The Spaghetti W/ Sausage & Peppers is a showcase of robust flavors, featuring juicy sausage sautéed with sweet peppers and caramelized onions, gently laid over al dente spaghetti. It's comfort food at its finest! If seafood is more your style, the Shrimp & Broccoli A La Mario astonishes with succulent shrimp and vibrant broccoli enveloped in a luscious pink sauce. Each dish carries a warmth that promises to make you feel right at home.

The dining atmosphere at Mario's is upscale yet relaxed, making it perfect for any occasion, whether it’s a cozy dinner for two or a lively celebration with friends and family. The attentive staff, led by the well-regarded server Nick M. who exemplifies top-notch service, is dedicated to ensuring each guest feels special and well cared for. His genuine warmth, along with the team's quick response to busy moments, adds to the restaurant's charm, creating an inviting ambience that fosters connection and joy.

On the special occasion of hosting events, the restaurant goes above and beyond. Customers have noted how the dedicated staff, like Peter, take meticulous care in planning, making intimate gatherings and celebrations truly memorable. Whether it’s a birthday party or family get-together, Mario’s skillful hospitality shines through, ensuring that every detail is tended to with pride.

But there’s more than just great food and service. The garlic knots served as part of the bread basket are a delightful start to your meal; their fluffy, doughy texture boasts a bouquet of aromatic garlic and butter, setting a delicious tone right from the get-go. Patrons have shared that each visit garners good memories and remarkable meals, with the Sicilian pizza as a staple on their return visits.

So whether you’re looking for a casual slice during your lunch break or planning a festive gathering, Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria invites you to experience their rich flavors and warm hospitality. With delicious food that lingers in your mind and a welcoming atmosphere, it truly is a staple of the Plainview community and a comforting spot to satisfy your culinary cravings.

Come and create your own memorable moments at Mario's – where every meal is a celebration of Italian tradition!

Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has outdoor seating
Offers kerbside pickup
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Serves great cocktails
Has great wine list
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves cocktails
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves spirits
Serves vegetarian dishes
Serves wine
Dining options
Serves brunch
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Family friendly
Good for groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Plenty of parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Saturday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Sunday

11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

408 Reviews
Ganesh

21 Sep 2025

I had a fantastic experience at Mario’s Ristorante in Plainview, and a big part of that was thanks to our server, Nick M. From the moment we were seated, Nick made us feel welcomed and taken care of. He was friendly, professional, and incredibly attentive without ever being overbearing. Nick had great recommendations, knew the menu inside and out, and made sure everything came out just right. He checked in at the perfect times, made us feel like valued guests, and added a personal touch that truly elevated the entire meal. The food, as always at Mario’s, was delicious—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. But the standout of the evening was the service. If you’re dining at Mario’s, I highly recommend asking for Nick M. He’s the kind of server who turns a good meal into a great experience

Tomahoe Prod

16 Aug 2025

We walked in , it was packed ,it seems a party of 20 just showed up . No worries for manager Narcis and the staff , they sat us down , and the family feeling set in . The food kept coming out , we we're able to view all the different dishes , everything looked and smelled so good . We ended up ordering a Chicken Marsala , a Zucchini Parmesan , Lasagna and Chicken Parmesan , everything was mouth watering great , When we finished , we couldn't budge , but we ordered dessert anyway. A chocolate Moose , Creme brulee cheesecake and a couple of Tartufo's . Thanks to Narcis and the staff for , not only a great meal but a great experience .

Nirmala S

25 Jul 2025

Nick M is truly an outstanding server, one of the best I've encountered ever. His warm, thoughtful, and personable approach makes our dining experiences even more enjoyable. The food here is consistently excellent, with the BBQ Chicken Pizza being a standout favorite. And the garlic knots served in the bread basket at the start of the meal are a delicious touch. Every restaurant would be lucky to have someone like Nick M on their team!

Mary Francis

23 Jul 2025

I love their pizza. I never miss going there when we visit Long Island. The Sicilian pizza is the best. Their dinners are great and they have great, friendly service.

ANDREA AKDAS

27 Jun 2025

I just had a 21st birthday party for my daughter this weekend. Peter was amazing on helping me put together all my details on contributing on making her night so wonderful. The service was amazing they went above and beyond, the food was beyond delicious and the atmosphere was perfect, a hidden jem for a party. I highly recommended!

swansong butterfly

23 Jun 2025

Amazing food served here ! Everything was fresh and delicious..definitely will be coming back. They also have 2 private rooms upsairs for parties. Real nice !

Checking
Listing Image

Marty's Grill

1000 Nevin Ave, Richmond, CA 94801, United States
Restaurant
(108 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Benny's Tacos & Rotisserie Chicken in Westchester

7101 W Manchester Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90045, United States
Mexican restaurant
(1779 Reviews)
Listing Image

Bursa Kebap Evi

1540 North Service Rd W, Oakville, ON L6M 4A1, Canada
(525 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Mexcal

516 S Virginia St, Reno, NV 89501, United States
Mexican restaurant
(848 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Pies 'n' Thighs

166 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Southern restaurant (US)
(3571 Reviews)

Join the Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.