Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria Menu

Welcome to Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Plainview, New York. This beloved eatery serves an extensive menu that combines classic Italian comfort with an inviting atmosphere. Begin your culinary journey with mouthwatering appetizers like Garlic Bread and Calamari Fritti, each dish bursting with flavor and perfectly prepared.

• Carne Entrees: Indulge in the Veal Sorrentino, where tender veal meets luscious mushroom sauce, or savor the Veal Parmigiana topped with homemade pomodoro.
• Fish Entrees: The Shrimp Parmigiana delights with its breaded shrimp and melted mozzarella, while the Salmon Semi Fredo presents a delightful medley of flavors.

Your dining experience is elevated by attentive service, with patrons frequently praising staff members like Nick M. Make sure to try their renowned BBQ Chicken Pizza or the legendary Sicilian pizza, beloved by all who visit. Mario's is truly a hidden gem!

Pizza Slices

• Marinara Slice

  Broccoli, mushrooms, spinach, peppers, onions, sauce and mozzarella.

  US$5.08

• Vegetable Slice

  Broccoli, mushrooms, spinach, peppers, onions, sauce and mozzarella.

  US$6.50

• Sicilian Slice

  Sweet BBQ chicken with mozzarella.

  US$4.72

• Chicken Marsala Slice

  Sautéed chicken with mushrooms, onions marsala wine and mozzarella.

  US$7.15

• Drunken Sicilian Slice

  Crispy chicken with broccoli, sweet tomato sauce and mozzarella.

  US$5.53

• BBQ Chicken Slice

  Sweet BBQ chicken with mozzarella.

  US$7.16

• Hot Honey Slice

  Margherita slice with cherry peppers and pepperoni and a drizzle of hot honey. A perfect balance of sweet and spicy.

  US$6.50

• Grandma Slice

  Sautéed chicken with mushrooms, onions marsala wine and mozzarella.

  US$5.53

• Chicken & Broccoli Slice

  Crispy chicken with broccoli, sweet tomato sauce and mozzarella.

  US$7.16

• Buffalo Chicken Slice

  Margherita slice with cherry peppers and pepperoni and a drizzle of hot honey. A perfect balance of sweet and spicy.

  US$7.15

• Regular Slice

  Buffalo spicy chicken with mozzarella. Served with a side of blue cheese or ranch dressing.

  US$4.72

Sides

• Side Burnt Broccoli

  US$13.00

• Side Broccoli Rabe

  US$13.00

• Side Sausage & Peppers (White)

  US$18.85

• Side Grilled Shrimp (6pc)

  US$13.00

• Side French Fries

  US$8.00

• Side Balsamic Chicken (2pc)

  US$13.00

• Side Crispy Shrimp (6pc)

  US$13.00

• Side Grilled Chicken (2pc)

  US$13.00

• Side Broccoli

  US$13.00

• Side Sausage & Peppers (Red)

  US$18.85

• Side Grilled Salmon

  US$11.50

• Side Crispy Chicken (2pc)

  US$13.00

Paninis & Wraps

• Chicken Caesar Wrap

  Grilled balsamic chicken, romaine lettuce, romano cheese, in our creamy caesar dressing, served with veggies or french fries.

  US$20.80

• Pollo Melanzane

  Grilled chicken, crispy eggplant, sun dried tomatoes and mozzarella, served with salad.

  US$20.80

• Panini Campagnola

  Sausage, roasted peppers, spinach and mozzarella, served with salad.

  US$20.80

• Panini Caprese

  Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, and tomatoes, served with a mixed salad.

  US$20.80

• Greek Wrap W/ Chicken

  US$20.80

• Panini Vegetarino

  Baked eggplant, zucchini, tomato and fresh mozzarella, served with mixed salad.

  US$20.80

• Panini Milanese

  Breaded chicken cutlet, arugula, tomato, served with mixed salad.

  US$20.80

Desserts

• Chocolate Mousse

  US$13.00

• Tartufo

  US$13.00

• Creme Brulee Cheesecake

  US$13.00

• Nutella Pizza

  US$13.00

• Fresh Strawberries & Whipped Cream

  US$13.00

• Cannoli

  US$11.70

• Tiramisu

  US$13.00

Large Pizzas

• 18" Tomato & Garlic

  US$39.65

• 18" Marios Special

  US$39.65

• 18" Chicken A La Vodka

  US$39.65

• 18" BBQ Chicken

  US$39.65

• 18" Baked Ziti

  US$39.65

• 16" Sicilian Square

  US$31.85

• 18" Bianca

  US$39.65

• 18" Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

  US$39.65

• 18" Chicken Stuffed

  US$39.65

• 16" Grandma Square

  US$31.85

• 16" Square Drunken Pizza

  US$39.65

• 18" Vegetable

  US$39.65

• 18" Chicken Marsala

  US$39.65

• 18" Buffalo Chicken

  US$39.65

• 18" Eggplant & Ricotta

  US$39.65

• Large 18" Plain

  US$27.30

• 18" Chicken & Broccoli

  US$39.65

• 16" Square Bruschetta

  US$39.65

• 18" Margherita Pizza

  US$33.00

• 18" Chicken Florentina

  US$39.65

• 18" Taco Pizza

  US$39.65

Pasta

• Spaghetti W/ Sausage & Peppers

  Always a favorite here at Mario's. Sliced sausage sautéed with sweet peppers and caramelized onions in our marinara or garlic and oil sauce over spaghetti pasta

  US$32.50

• Shrimp & Broccoli A La Mario

  Pan seared shrimp, broccoli, mushrooms in pink sauce with pasta.

  US$36.40

• Spaghetti With Meatballs (New Style)

  Mario's famous meatballs with spaghetti.

  US$27.30

• Shrimp Scampi

  Jumbo shrimp, lemon, garlic, and paprika in a scampi sauce served with pasta or salad.

  US$36.40

• Lasagna

  Meat filled (all beef) mixed cheeses, tomato sauce and melded mozzarella casserole.

  US$27.30

• Penne Bolognese

  Gluten-free available. penne pasta in a creamy meat sauce.

  US$27.30

• Stuffed Shells

  Jumbo pasta shells filled with ricotta cheese, tomato sauce and mozzarella baked casserole.

  US$26.00

• Whole Wheat Penne Pesto

  Gluten-free available. whole wheat pasta with grilled balsamic chicken in a fresh basil pesto sauce.

  US$32.50

• Baked Ziti

  US$22.10

• Fusilli A La Putanesca

  Gluten-free available. spiral pasta with ground anchovies, capers and kalamata olives in a light spicy pomodoro sauce.

  US$27.30

• Fettuccini Alfredo

  Heavy cream & Pecorino Romano sauce.

  US$26.00

• Spaghetti Carbonara

  Gluten-free available. bacon, egg, parmesan.

  US$27.30

• Penne A La Vodka

  Our famous vodka sauce done our way with mushrooms & onions

  US$27.30

• Rigatoni Campagnola

  Sweet Italian sausage with spinach, roasted peppers, broccoli in a garlic & oil broth.

  US$32.50

• Chicken Scarpariello

  Gluten-free available. sausage, potatoes, zucchini, onions, red pepper and chicken sautéed with garlic, wine and lemon.

  US$33.80

• Rigatoni Florentina

  Sautéed chicken pieces with spinach and shredded fresh mozzarella cheese in a blush sauce with rigatoni pasta.

  US$32.50

• Whole Wheat Penne Primavera

  Gluten-free available. whole wheat penne pasta served with fresh vegetables in your choice of sauce (marinara or garlic & oil).

  US$31.60

• Frutti Di Mare

  Shrimp, mussels and clams with your choice of marinara or a zesty garlic and oil sauce.

  US$39.65

• Linguine Al Vongole

  Fresh manila clams sautéed in garlic white wine and virgin olive oil or our homemade marinara sauce.

  US$33.80

• Linguine Oreganata

  Baked shrimp with white wine, fresh garlic, herbs and sprinkled breadcrumbs with pecorino romano. served with al dente linguine.

  US$36.40

• Baked Ravioli

  Cheese ravioli with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.

  US$23.40

• Create Your Own Pasta

  US$21.80

• Penne Al La Casserole

  Gluten-free available. crushed tomato, garlic, mozzarella and eggplant in a light filetto sauce.

  US$27.30

• Fusilli Al Paillard

  Tender grilled balsamic chicken sautéed with fresh broccoli rabe and red peppers in zesty garlic and oil.

  US$27.30

Salads

• Mozzarella Wedge

  Romaine wedge, bacon, chopped tomato, shredded mozz, cherry peppers, house Italian dressing.

  US$20.80

• LG Antipasto Salad

  Ham, salami, pepperoni, soppressata, provolone, tomato, cucumber, black olives, radishes, lettuce, cabbage.

  US$20.80

• LG Greek Salad

  Crispy lettuce with feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, kalamata olives, tomatoes and onions with house italian dressing.

  US$18.20

• LG Caesar Salad

  Crispy romaine lettuce, homemade caesar dressing, croutons, Romano cheese.

  US$15.60

• Mediterraneo

  Blackened spicy chicken breast with fresh mozzarella, bruschetta, fresh avocado slices and cilantro rice dressed with lime & olive oil.

  US$27.30

• LG Tri-Color Salad

  Tri-color greens, roasted peppers, diced tomatoes, red onions, croutons and warm toasted goat cheese with our homemade raspberry vinaigrette.

  US$18.20

• LG Tossed Garden Salad

  Mixed lettuce with, tomato, cucumbers, radishes, shredded carrots and Kalamata olives. Italian dressing.

  US$14.30

• LG Gorgonzola Salad

  Assorted greens mixed with roasted peppers, diced tomatoes, and crumbled gorgonzola cheese in our homemade raspberry vinaigrette.

  US$18.20

Pizzette

• Pizzette Baked Ziti

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Eggplant & Ricotta

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Plain

  US$16.90

• Pizzette Buffalo Chicken

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Chicken A La Vodka

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Tomato & Garlic

  US$22.75

• Pizzette BBQ Chicken

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Marios Specials

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Taco Pizza

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Bianca

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Grandma

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Chicken & Broccoli

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Margherita Pizza

  US$21.75

• Pizzette Bruschetta

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Chicken Stuffed

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Chicken Florentina

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Drunken Pizza

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Chicken Marsala

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Vegetable

  US$22.75

• Pizzette Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

  US$22.75

Heros

• Chicken Cutlet W/Lettuce, Tomato And Caper Mayo

  Crispy or grilled chicken with Lettuce, tomato and caper mayo.

  US$19.50

• Grilled Chicken Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers

  US$20.80

• Veal Parm Hero

  US$22.10

• Eggplant Parm Hero

  US$17.55

• Shrimp Parm Hero

  US$21.45

• Sausage W/ Peppers & Onions Hero

  US$18.20

• Italian Cold Cut Hero

  US$20.80

• Chicken Francaise Hero

  US$20.80

• Egg Hero

  Traditional egg omelet in a sandwich. Have it any way you like. With sauce and provolone of your choice of potatoes, sausage or whatever you like!

  US$17.60

• Meatball & Parm Hero

  US$18.20

• Sausage Parm Hero

  US$18.20

• Chicken Parm Hero

  US$19.50

Veggie Entrees

• Eggplant Rolatine

  Crispy eggplant stuffed with ricotta & with or without ham, baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella. Served with salad or pasta.

  US$34.50

Chicken Entrees

• Chicken Primavera

  Balsamic marinated or cajun-spiced chicken breast served with a vegetable medley.

  US$33.80

• Mediterraneo

  Blackened spicy chicken breast with fresh mozzarella, bruschetta, fresh avocado slices and cilantro rice dressed with lime & olive oil.

  US$29.30

• Chicken Marsala

  Chicken breast with sautéed mushrooms and onions in our homemade marsala wine sauce. Served with choice of pasta.

  US$37.10

• Chicken Francaise

  Chicken breast served in lemon butter sauce with broccoli. Served with choice of pasta.

  US$37.10

• Chicken Portofino

  Grilled chicken breast topped with sautéed broccoli rabe, roasted peppers and fresh melted mozzarella cheese. Served with spaghetti pasta in a tomato sauce.

  US$38.40

• Chicken Valenciana (Deep Copy)

  US$37.70

• Chicken Verde

  Battered breast of chicken topped with fresh broccoli and melted mozzarella in a white wine and light marinara sauce. Served with your choice of pasta.

  US$38.40

• Chicken Romano

  Panko crusted chicken breast pan fried in a plum tomato & lemon sauce with a hint of cream & locatelli cheese. Served with spaghetti pasta

  US$35.80

• Chicken Parmigiana

  Classic chicken parmigiana served with your choice of pasta or salad

  US$34.50

Carne Entrees

• Veal Sorrentino

  Sliced eggplant, prosciutto and fresh melted mozzarella, served with our famous mushroom sauce and your choice of pasta or salad.

  US$42.30

• Veal Parmigiana

  Tender cut veal with melted mozzarella in our homemade pomodoro sauce with your choice of pasta or salad.

  US$39.70

Soups

• Stracciatella Soup

  US$11.70

• Pasta E Fagiole

  Pasta & canellini beans. All vegan.

  US$11.70

• Tortellini E Brodo

  US$11.70

• Minestrone Soup

  Hearty vegetable soup. All Vegan.

  US$11.70

• Chicken Noodle Soup

  US$11.70

• Escarole & Bean Soup

  Escarole greens, cannelini beans, touch of crushed tomato, veggie broth. All vegan

  US$11.70

Calzones

• Stromboli

  Ham, salami, provolone, pepperoni, mozzarella

  US$14.30

• Buffalo Chicken Roll

  Buffalo style chicken with mozzarella, bleu cheese optional

  US$14.30

• Pepperoni Pinwheel

  US$9.10

• Cheese Calzone

  Ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan

  US$13.00

• Chicken Roll

  Crispy chicken strips, mozzarella, and tomato sauce

  US$14.30

• Sausage, Peppers, Onion Roll

  Sausage, roasted peppers, caramelized onions, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce

  US$14.30

• Spinach Pinwheel

  US$9.10

• Spinach Roll

  Spinach, mozzarella, feta, parmesan

  US$14.30

Appetizers..

• Garlic Bread

  US$9.10

• Wings (8pc)

  US$20.80

• Mario's Homemade Meatballs

  Skillet seared meatballs in homemade pomodoro sauce.

  US$20.80

• Baked Clams Oreganate (6pc)

  US$20.80

• Calamari Fritti

  Golden fried calamari served with our marinara or sweet chili sauce

  US$22.10

• Chicken Tenders (3)

  Try our homemade chicken tenders made with our secret spices! Served with your choice of bbq, ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard or tomato sauce.

  US$15.60

• Arancini

  Meat and pea filled rice ball. served in our famous romano sauce.

  US$15.60

• Burrata

  Served with arugula and tomatoes in a balsamic glaze.

  US$20.80

• Bruschetta

  US$18.20

• Mozzarella Sticks

  Gluten-free available. five pieces golden fried served with plum tomato sauce

  US$15.60

• Eggplant Rolatine

  US$9.10

Drinks

• Pellegrino Sparkling

  US$3.90

• Diet Dr. Pepper

  US$3.90

• Dr. Pepper

  US$3.90

• Coke Zero

  US$3.90

Fish Entrees

• Shrimp Parmigiana

  Breaded shrimp (6) with melted mozzarella in our homemade pomodoro sauce. Served with your choice of pasta or salad

  US$39.70

• Salmon Semi Fredo

  Grilled salmon served with a romano sauce, asparagus, spinach with vegetable rice

  US$39.00